A congressional hopeful backed by the Democratic Socialists of America has argued that the violent past of a man shot by ICE agents in the Bronx should not be held against him.
Darializa Avila Chevalier, who is running in New York’s 13th District, told online host Hasan Piker that Oscar Belgal was simply trying to protect his five-year-old son when he drove away from federal agents.
She said the man’s record “doesn’t even matter” to her.
What Took Place in Marble Hill
On the afternoon of October 8, ICE agents in plain clothes approached Belgal’s SUV while he was picking up his son from school. When he tried to leave, agents fired into the vehicle and hit him in the neck. He is now being held in federal custody.
Officials say Belgal came into the country illegally in 2022. His record includes a 2023 conviction for armed robbery and a 2025 arrest tied to the sale of fentanyl, cocaine, and heroin.
He has also been linked to the Trinitarios street gang. Some former neighbors claimed he once threatened people in his building with a machete.
Chevalier’s Response
Chevalier criticized Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch for highlighting Belgal’s background instead of criticizing ICE’s action. She said any parent in that moment would try to shield their child and called for Belgal’s release. She again asked for Tisch to step down and closed the interview by saying ICE should be shut down.
The shooting led to protests in the Bronx demanding that federal immigration officers leave the city. Both Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Commissioner Tisch said the NYPD had not been told about the operation in advance.
Different Views of the Same Events
People who agree with Chevalier say dwelling on someone’s past can distract from how the encounter was handled. Others argue that a history of violence is relevant when judging both public safety and the decision to make the arrest.
The case remains in the spotlight as city and federal officials face pressure from opposing sides over how New York enforces immigration rules.
When the System Suddenly Feels Personal
Moments like this show how fast an ordinary day can turn into a serious legal fight. If you or someone you care about is dealing with federal charges, an immigration-related case, or questions about an old record, reach out.
Leave your details on the form or call the office. We will listen first, then explain what the next steps look like in plain language.
